As a fan, I could complain about how Avenue 5 was treated, but the truth is, it was a very quirky show filling a niche that wasn’t exactly huge. It made it all the way to production and distribution because creator Armando Iannuzzi had a sweetheart deal giving HBO the first crack at anything he created, and he created a caustic comedy about a space cruise ship gone astray. That it was a sci-fi comedy on a pay-cable-channel-morphing-into-a-streaming-service already put Avenue 5 at a disadvantage in terms of eyeballs; that it landed right at the beginning of the COVID-19 pandemic should’ve given it a chance to be sampled by more people… except that the same pandemic inevitably delayed production of a second season, making it easy to think the show was dead when it wasn’t. (When the second season did arrive, the lackadaisical promotional push for it pretty much confirmed that HBO, at least, had already decided the show was dead, and an official cancellation followed shortly thereafter.) It was impossible timing for a show that wanted to stick around, though one of its episodes – one in which the passengers, led by a particularly clueless rumormonger, ceases to even believe that the show is in space and starts demanding to walk out the airlocks – was one of the best-timed episodes in the history of television. Though written and shot nearly a year before COVID, and probably intended to target climate science denialists, it perfectly encapsulated everything about that early stage of the pandemic when disinformation was starting its alarming spread through the internet.
And the show’s music, seldom foregrounded, just seemed weird – intentionally dissonant, almost like it was sticking its tongue out at the kind of grand orchestrations that usually accompany lovingly detailed shots of massive spaceships on TV. It was far enough down in the show’s sound mix that it was hard to gauge sometimes, but I found it intriguing enough that I was delighted – and, to be honest, very surprised – to see a soundtrack release. And it surprised me even more when it actually stood up as a listening experience without the rest of the show. That’s not always the case with a sitcom. (Then again, there’s actually an album of all of those bass licks from Seinfeld, so what do I know?) Sitcom music tends to be transitional – it gets over a time jump in the story, but seldom serves a dramatic purpose, and isn’t necessarily memorable.
The music for Avenue 5 is different, because Iannuzzi specializes in biting satire. Better known for In The Thick Of It (the series that put Peter Capaldi on the radar as its foulmouthed breakout star) and Veep (an American take on In The Thick Of It, starring Julia Louis-Dreyfuss, produced for HBO), Iannuzzi sets up terrible situations, often full of terrible or incompetent people, winds them up, and lets them go. It’s baked into the cake of Avenue 5 that each episode will land on a schadenfreude-laden callback to every problem that everyone’s been warned about earlier in the show, and that’s usually where Ilhan made his musical presence known.
There are some tracks, such as “The Continuing Journey” and “Your Ears Are Beautiful, To Me”, which are just gorgeous – this is what you’re supposed to hear in a show where an enormous, luxurious spaceship lumbers past the camera! – but the “house style” for Avenue 5’s music seems to be more of a trippy flavor of sound collage. Incomplete vocal samples, chugging cellos and bassoons and bass clarinets that never quite seem to be perfectly in tune (very much like the characters aboard the aforementioned luxurious spaceship), and rapid-fire rhythms that remind me of some of Kronos Quartet’s more offbeat experiments. (I actually found myself thinking of Kronos Quartet a lot on the first listen; this is a compliment.) Some tracks start out as traditional pieces of dramatic scoring before oddball elements creep in and things get weird, such as “It’s All Gonna Be Fine” and “Orbiting”. Some tracks, like “Mmm Ba Deep” and “Newton’s… Third Law”, start weird and stay weird, in some cases pouring on additional weird. It all fits the show perfectly, but the surprising thing is how well it stands up as music. It helps if you’re an Avenue 5 fan going in, but it’s a fascinating set of musical experiments designed to tell the listener “something’s going wrong here, and it’s about to start going even wronger.”
As a soundtrack, Avenue 5 is as quirky, unconventional, and weird as the show this music accompanied – and that’s kind of a beautiful thing. It makes for a surprisingly effective standalone listen.
- The Continuing Journey (01:45)
- Mmm Ba Deep (02:19)
- Go Up There And Smile (00:54)
- Newton’s… Third Law (01:04)
- The Key Word Is Walk (01:59)
- Your Ears Are Beautiful, To Me (01:55)
- Inside (01:31)
- Bearing (02:27)
- It Stands For Visual Effects (01:03)
- Aaargh (01:20)
- Back On Earth (01:58)
- Big Yellow (01:17)
- It’s All Gonna Be Fine (01:10)
- Tense Is My Middle Name (01:36)
- I Don’t Want To Use My Sweet Moves (03:12)
- Oh Oh Oh Five (01:35)
- Walk With Me (02:37)
- Unclench Me (02:19)
- Knotted Bedsheets (01:58)
- Orbiting (03:39)
- Like Psychosis But With None Of The Benefits (01:16)
Released by: Lakeshore Records
Release date: November 3, 2022
Total running time: 38:36